On "Idol," Hooters and Michael Feinstein


A few random comments, from my temporary Hollywood outpost:

1) During a Los Angeles bus ride this week, I saw a Hooters restaurant and was confused. Why, in Los Angeles, would anyone need to go to a Hooters?

2) Is it good news that Nigel Lythgoe is taking over "American Idol"? Probably. Lythgoe does a great job at "So You Think You Can Dance," where his passion clearly lies. It's good to hear that he favors three "Idol" judges instead of four (although he might have four anyway) and that he wants to give the singers a chance for bigger productions. Other changes are needed, however, to make sure that the more distinctive contestants aren't dumped before getting to the final 12. Also, judges need to quit insisting that every contestant, on every song, follows the mantra of "make it your own." Sometimes, a straight-on rendition can be perfect.

3) I missed Wednesday's "So You Think You Can Dance," but I'll catch up tonight, when the show picks its three dancers for next week's finale. Things have been busy out here at the Television Critics Association sessions, peaking with a great night last night. Backed by a 17-piece band, Michael Feinstein -- whose latest show reaches PBS on Oct. 6, 13 and 20 -- gave a sensational concert. If you ever get a chance to hear this guy with a big band, do it. "American songbook" classics are performed with swing, zest and consummate skill.

 

 

 

"American Idol" -- mostly, questions


If I had my way, "America Idol" would trim back to three judges next season, possibly Randy Jackson, Bret Michaels and Shania Twain.



There would also be a system to let judges choose three of the final 12, to make sure the who;e thing doesn't become as bland as it was this year. And I'd beg judges to quit telling everyone to always "make it your own"; sometimes, a great rendition of the original version is its own reward.

I don't have my way, of course -- and so far, Fox hasn't decided anything either. Here's the story I sent to papers today:

By MIKE HUGHES

LOS ANGELES -- A month before “American Idol”
needs its judges, the show still has an information vacuum.

Peter Rice, chairman of the Fox
network, refused Monday to confirm or deny any of the rumors. He
wouldn't say whether Randy Jackson or Kara DioGuardi will be back …
whether Simon Lythgoe will take over as producer … or even whether
there will be three or four judges.

The only definite thing, Rice said, is
that Ellen Degeneres won't be a judge.

She had said in early June that she
wasn't comfortable on the show, Rice said. “I tried to persuade her
that it would be different in the future.”

At first, he said, Fox wasn't sure
about letting her leave. He approved that recently, “when we felt
confident that we can come up with a panel that doesn't include
(her).”

Simon Cowell is also leaving, to create
an American version of “The It Factor,” which will reach Fox in
the fall of 2011. That means “Idol” could have as many as four
new judges; Names that have surfaced include Jennifer Lopez, Sean
“Diddy” Combs, Bret Michaels, Elton John, Shania Twain and Harry
Connick Jr.

Auditions have already started. Rice
said 16,000 contestants showed up in Nashville, 10,000 in New
Orleans; Milwaukee also had try-outs, with others coming to East
Rutherford, N.J. (Tuesday, Aug. 3); Austin, Texas (Aug. 11); and San
Francisco (Aug. 19).

In this first round staffers pick the
best and worst singers, to audition for the judges. By sometime next
month, Rice said, the next round – and the judges – should be in
place.

“Idol” is the most-watched show on
TV, but ratings fell this season. “It's going to be in its 10th
season and Simon's departure (made this) a time to evolve,” Rice
said.

The key often involves which people
become finalists, said Mike Darnell, Fox's reality-show chief. “I
still think season five was one of the best, because each person was
distinctive.”

Many of the contestants that year –
Chris Daughtry, Kellie Pickler, Elliott Yamin, Bucky Covington, plus
champion Taylor Hicks and runner-up Katharine McPhee – landed
record deals. “The fact that I can remember them all shows what a
good group it was,” Darnell said.

Adam Lambert, from the 2009 season, is
already headlining a large tour this summer. “With Adam, you always
knew he was going to do something special with a song,” Darnell
said.

Critics have grumbled that recent
winners have been bland. Kris Allen beat Lambert that year; Lee
DeWyze won this year. Darnell ducks that; “it's all in the alchemy,
the mix of people,” he said.

Whatever happens, Rice argued, the
basic concept still works. “Someone literally is standing in a line
in Nashville and can have a No. 1 record 10 months later. That's
great television.”

 

 

 

Talking to Shaq


As the Television Critics Association mixer neared, ABC said there were a few additions. One was Shaquille O'Neal.

"Will he be wearing a name tag?" I asked.

That wasn't really needed, of course. Shaq is listed at 7-foot-1 and 325 pounds, but seems bigger. He's not the tallest person I've interviewed -- the late Kevin Peter Hall was 7-foot-2 -- but he's close. Since he talks quietly -- and from well above my ears -- the tough part was simply hearing everything. Here's the story I sent to papers:



By MIKE HUGHES

LOS ANGELES – When you imagine a
spelling bee, you might think of little kids with big glasses and big
words.

You don;t think of Shaq.

Still, Shaquille O'Neal says he did
well in his childhood bee. “I finished second,” he said. “I
almost got to go to Washington, D.C.”

Now he has a second chance. When “Shaq
vs.” returns Tuesday (Aug. 3), he'll compete with the 15-year-old
National Spelling Bee champion.

O'Neal was talking about this Sunday
night, at an ABC mixer with the Television Critics Association. For
reporters, it was a chance for quick one-on-one interviews – amid
logistical problems.

Listed as 7-foot-1 and 325 pounds,
O'Neal was dressed elegantly – dark suitcoat, dark vest, bow tie –
and talk\ed quietly. Arms stretched upward, to get tape-recorders
close enough to catch him.

No longer with the Cleveland Cavaliers
– who also lost LeBron James between seasons – he isn't sure
where he'll play basketball this season. His four NBA championships
(and three most-valuable-player awards in the finals) are now six
years behind him. During the recent play-offs, he was (at 38), the
oldest man in the league.

What he does know is that ABC has been
his summer home. First was “Shaq's Big Challenge,” in which he
pushed kids to exercise … and schools to re-instate physical
education.

“It's getting worse,” O'Neal said.
“A lot of schools are cutting out their programs. When we were
young, our parents would say, 'Go outside and play.' Now there's
technology and videogames.”

Last summer, “Shaq vs.” had O'Neal
facing athletes in their own events. Now the show expands to an hour
and includes two things – one non-physical. O'Neal spells in the
opener, does magic a week later.

Still, the physical challenges may be
the biggest draw. In the opener, O'Neal races against NASCAR driver
Dale Earnhardt Jr. “It was terrifying,” he said.

He had a special car built that he
could fit into. “You have six seatbelts, but it's still scary.”

It was the toughest thing he's faced,
he said – even scarier than facing a spelling-bee champion.

– Shaq. Vs.,” 9:01 to 10 p.m.
Tuesdays, ABC; most stations will rerun it at 3 p.m. Saturdays.

– Opener (Aug. 3) has Shaquille
O'Neal facing racer Dale Earnhardt Jr. and spelling-bee champion
Kavya Shivashankar; second week has 150-pound boxer Shane Mosley and
magicians Penn-and-Teller.

– Other weeks will include singer
Justin Bieber, chef Rachael Ray and hot-dog eater Joey Chestnut.

 

 

Paul Lee at ABC: Oxford to the rescue


The networks are often very kind to Television Critics Association people. They stir up some sort of newsy chaos whenever we visit them in Los Angeles.

This time, it was the abrupt changeover at ABC. Fortunately, the network had a good programmer ready to fill the sudden hole. Here's the story I sent to papers; I'm putting it here right away, becase of the time factor:




By MIKE HUGHES

LOS ANGELES – After a sudden and
dizzying change, ABC might seem to have a mismatch.

Gone is Stephen McPherson, who molded
the network's programming for six years. Amid reports of
sexual-harassment accusations, the network has had a no-comment
stance.

Stepping in is Paul Lee, sort of
McPherson's opposite. He's a quiet Englishman, an Oxford grad.

Yes, that's a surprise. This network –
with “American” in its title and Mickey Mouse in its DNA – is
run by an Englishman. An outside perspective can be fine, Lee told
reporters Sunday.

“Being an outsider – either by
country or by age – (is) a real motive to do a lot of research,”
he said.

For six years, Lee programmed ABC
Family, which was girl-oriented. “I've just spent the last six
years trying to channel … my inner female teen,” he said.

He succeeded, usually with shows that
included warmth and hope.

Lee tried fantasy shows; “Middle Man”
failed – “I adored that show (but) it was the wrong show for the
network” – but “Kyle XY” succeeded. He scored with TV movies,
failed with reality shows, had a clever comedy (“10 Things I Hate
About You”) and a praised family drama (“Lincoln Heights”).

Mostly, he succeeded with dramas
focusing on teens – in sororities (“Greek”), in gymnastics
meets (“Make It or Break It”) or in trouble (“The Secret Life
of the American Teenager”). This summer, he scored with two more
teen dramas, “Pretty Little Liars” and “Huge.”

Then came the abrupt change by the
Disney-owned network: On Tuesday (July 27), ABC issued a terse
statement that McPherson had resigned; it phoned Lee, who was
vacationing on a California beach.

When he met reporters Sunday morning,
he'd been on the job for 36 hours. This was not a time for substance;
Lee mentioned “Modern Family five times, mentioned his wife six
times.

It was, however, a time to set a mood.
Lee looks like actor Jim Parsons (Sheldon on “Big Bang Theory”)
and sounds like a beloved English teacher; his master's degree is in
modern languages.

He's not the first Oxford man to run a
network; CBS thrived when Howard Stringer was in charge. More often,
Ivy Leaguers are at the top. Until recently, two networks were
programmed by friends – McPherson and Fox's Kevin Reilly – who
were Phi Delta Theta fraternity brothers at Cornell.

Many network people are outsiders,
guessing the tastes of Middle America. Instincts help, Lee said. “If
a show doesn't really move you or hit you in the gut,” it won't
work.

And testing? The British “The
Office,” he said, “was the worst-tested show I had ever tested in
my life,” then became an international hit. Still, he sees
advantages to research. “Ignore testing at your peril, because it
will often tell you weaknesses that you are too self-deceptive to
realize.”

There are plenty of strong ABC shows,
Lee said. He mentioned “Modern Family,” “Grey's Anatomy,”
“Desperate Housewives,” “Dancing With the Stars” and the
summer success of “Bachelorette.”

McPherson helped nurture all of them;
with the just-departed “Lost,” he proved that a quirky show can
succeed. “So many of the brand-defining shows on this network have
been wonderful, serialized appointment television that nobody can not
watch within four hours,” Lee said.

McPherson prepared a fall schedule that
has standard shows and quirky ones. “My Generation” spans a
decade, “Better Together” spans a generation, “No Ordinary
Family” has accidental superpowers.

Don't expect Lee to change that now.
“We're locked and loaded,” he said. Changes “can make more
damage than good.”

The shows will debut in September, as
scheduled. It will be Steve McPherson's line-up on Paul Lee's
network. Two outsiders – from Cornell and Oxford – reach for the
American mid-section.

 

 

ABC and Paul Lee: A good choice


Here are a few of my comments from Los Angeles, where the Television Critics Association is meeting:

1) McPherson out; Lee in:

Given an awful situation, ABC made a smart move by giving its top programming job to Paul Lee. Before he took over, he did a terrific job at ABC Family.

The hole came this week when Steve McPherson suddenly resigned, just as ABC was preparing to launch its new season. Reports (including a Reuters report in newyorkdailynews.com) said the company had been investigating him for sexual harassment.

Overall, McPherson had done a good job. On his watch, ABC came up with enough distinctive shows -- "Lost," "Desperate Housewives," "Modern Family," "The Middle" -- to hold viewers' interest during a time of crumbling ratings.

But ABC -- owned by Disney -- must pursue reports of misbehavior. It happened to have the perfect person in-house.

Lee ran BBC America, then took over ABC Family. There, his shows have ranged from adequate ("The Secret Life of the American Teenager," "Make It or Break It") to surprisingly good ("Huge," the summer's best surprise, plus "Pretty Little Liars" and several of the movies). He's the best guy for a bad situation.

2) Billy Bell's gone.

Yes, it's kind of startling to realize Billy Bell is gone from "So You Think You Can Dance."

Here was a remarkable talent who never quite clicked with viewers. He kept being in the bottom three; this week, he and Jose Ruiz -- a stunning solo talent who did his best to learn duets -- failed to make the final four.

Nigel Lythgoe, the show's creator and judge, said this might be because of his "slightly androgynous style." Lythgoe likes guys who "dance like a dude"; others might have trouble drawing the little-girl votes.

I'd guess this was more because he rarely projected warmth. He finally did during a brilliant duet Wednesday with Ade; it was, apparently, too late to soften his image.

3) Chased away.

In some sort of press-tour record, NBC allotted all of 20 minutes for the fall show, "Chase." Its other shows get 30; in other times, they got 40. That makes sense, I suppose; there wasn't time to ask about some of the hugest plot holes in crime-show history.